Email us: themattressexpert@live.com
Call Us: 1-856-874-6894

Exchanging a Serta icomfort mattress.


Anna writes:

I’ve been reading your website and am impressed with your answers to people. We bought a Serta Icomfort Prodigy memory foam mattress from a local store about 45 days ago. We have not slept at all. We had a firm tempurpedic in the past that was fine, but was worn out and was hot. We can go to American Signature and reselect another mattress. Due to back and hip pain, we got the memory foam. I’ve read what you think of them. We sink into this way to much and have to “climb” our way out of the bed to turn over or get up. It sounds like we need to select a Simmons Beauty Rest firm mattress and get a latex topper from you. The store apparently renames the various versions of the mattresses. Do you know which we should select according to their names? We want a queen again since we sleep very close and like our current adjustable bed frame. We are tall, husband is 6’1.5” and weights 240. I am 5’11” and weigh 160. 

I may have to stick with the Serta brand, since Icomfort is Serta.  If I have to stick with Serta which would be your recommendation that they carry at American Signature stores?  From reading more it sounds like the 2 in. latex soft is best. Which latex topper is best for us and feels cooler? 

Thank you! Anna
Hi Anna,


If you must opt for a Serta, go with a firm innerspring model with as little padding as possible and add the latex topper.
You must check to see if they are compatible with an adjustable bed base. 
If they have the Simmons World Class Series, go with the least expensive model in firm. 
The Simmons is compatible with your bed base.
A 2" soft Talalay Latex topper is what you'll want for comfort…unless you prefer a firmer surface feel.
If so, go with the Dunlop topper. All of the latex toppers sleep cool…unlike memory foam. And unlike chemical based memory foam, the latex toppers are all-natural.
Both are shown here:
Latex Mattress Topper

Latex Mattress Topper



Thanks, Pete

Phone: 1-856-874-6894 
Email: themattressexpert@live.com

Website: https://themattressexpert.com/

Factory Direct to You….All Items Made Factory Fresh to Fill Your Order

Free Delivery Nationwide….US & Canada…NO SALES TAX.



Questions, Comments, Concerns?

Please Check out One of our Blogs Listed below Or Ask us on Facebook or Twitter.

You can Also Call or Email Us!

E-mail: themattressexpert@live.com
Phone: 1-856-874-6894

Like us on Facebook

Follow Us On Twitter

Latest Posts