Email us: pete.themattressexpert@gmail.com
Call Us: 1-856-874-6894

A Replacement for a 2008 Stearns and Foster Plaza Plush Mattress.

John writes:
Hi Pete,

Could you recommend a replacement for a 2008 Stearns and Foster Plaza Plush mattress in Cal King size? 
I prefer a cooler mattress top as I sometimes sweat while sleeping.


Hi John,

Tempurpedic bought Sealy and S&F 5 years after you bought that mattress.
In January 2014, S&F went from being the Cadillac of the industry, to nothing more than expensive junk.
In short, there is no replacement model.
However, I can closely mimic the feel, quality and longevity.
The question becomes, “Which mattress?”.
The best choice depends on the weight it has support.
What are the sizes, heights and weights of those using the mattress?
A list of physical ailments is also helpful.
It appears you’re using a waterproof mattress protector.
While they do a great job of helping to maximize the life of the mattress, many of them sleep hot. Here’s a link to one that won’t cause you to sleep hot.


Thanks, Pete
Hi Pete,
Myself: 180 lbs, 5′-10, side sleeper
My significant other: 115 lbs, 5′-3″, back sleeper
No significant ailments for either of us.  
I generally sleep with a pillow between my legs.  
We both prefer a plush feel.
Thanks for your suggestions.


Hi John,

I could tell the feel you wanted by the photo you sent.
Finding a mattress with the feel of your S&F is easy.
All the major brands have mattresses that feel the same.
What they don’t have are mattresses that feel like that, that will last for more than a couple of years…even at your sizes.
The difference is the upholstery material used today…memory foam.
Yours is upholstered with polyurethane foam….and maybe a little latex.
Latex is and has been the best of the foams, for the last 100 years.
To best mimic the feel of your mattress with products that will last for many years, my recommendation comes in two parts.
First, is the mattress…The Natura of Canada Greenspring in Ultra Plush…Shown here:

Add to that, …Shown here:
Together, you’ll achieve the luxurious feel you’re looking for, and have it for many years to come.
Over time, all you’ll need to replace is the topper. With the topper on it, the mattress will last for decades.
Doing it this way, it’s likely that this will be the last mattress you’ll need to buy.
The mattress comes with white glove delivery, which includes set-up and removal of your old mattress.
The latex topper arrives via UPS.
Delivery, for both, is free and there’s no sales tax.

Thanks, Pete

Phone: 856-874-6894


Questions, Comments, Concerns?

Please Check out One of our Blogs Listed below Or Ask us on Facebook or Twitter.

You can Also Call or Email Us!

E-mail: pete.themattressexpert@gmail.com

Phone: 1-856-874-6894

Like us on Facebook

Follow Us On Twitter

Latest Posts